Hearts and Minds

In the mid 70’s the Peter Davis’ documentary on the Vietnam War Hearts and Minds*  was being shown at anything vaguely political. I must have been about 21 when I first saw it, a powerful film which made me angry and justified my politics. I watched it again yesterday for probably the first time in 40 years, quite expecting to find it naïve, dated and unshocking. It wasn’t. It felt as powerful as it ever did.

The genius in its making was the editing and the chilling simplicity in allowing people to talk, not questioning their assumptions, but letting their true selves come through. The editing of General Westmorland happily sitting next to a lake at home in the sunshine telling the viewer how Asian people don’t have the same value for life as Americans, mixed with a broken North Vietnamese father telling how his family were all killed by the bombing showing where each had died, and a South Vietnamese family burying their soldier son/father the family totally paralysed with grief.

Hearts and Minds was made within months of the fall of Saigon, the wounds raw. Men recently returned to the USA unable to justify to themselves what they had done, telling how they were just following their training doing their job. Vietnamese wondering what it was all for, their homes and land disintegrated under the fighting, bombing and chemical spraying.

There are many of the iconic images of that terrible war such as the naked children whose skin is falling off after being bombed with napalm running up the road; the shooting in the head of the suspect in the street; the burning of a village by bored young soldiers, all as powerful as they ever were. These are set alongside the justifications by politicians and images of ordinary American life.

A telling statement which I hadn’t remembered was by a man whose farm had been wiped out, he turned to the camera and said “…first you bomb us, then you film us…”, which made being a viewer an uneasy experience.

If you haven’t seen it I would urge people to do so, it is a powerful piece of film-making and still relevant today.

*link to a YouTube posting of  film


3 thoughts on “Hearts and Minds

  1. Unspeakable. Every war left negative things till the present days. My grandma had pregnant, gave births & breastfed (no formula/cow milk for babies at that time) to my mom and her 2 siblings during 1942-1948 in Indonesia, during Japanese occupation, independence war & twice NICA (the World War II winner) aggressions with all the apparatus e.g Professional soldiers. Even our family was very lucky than many others, despite at that time when everything was difficult, lack of food/nutrition, walk to other cities for refuges/run to avoid bombings with kids etc, my grandma still get the war effect. Now she (will turn 99 this year), and many other women who pregnants & give births at that time, has been suffering bad osteoporosis, lost teeth at early times.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.